Injured at a Hotel or Resort: How the Claim Works

A hotel guest is an invitee, a person on the premises for the owner's business, and is owed the highest duty premises law recognizes: the operator must inspect for hazards, repair them, and warn of those it cannot repair. The duty covers the rooms, the common areas, the pool and fitness areas, the restaurants and bars, the parking facilities and the grounds, and it extends to the conduct of staff and, through security, to protection from foreseeable crime.

The claim is that a dangerous condition existed, the operator knew or should have known of it, it failed to address it, and the condition caused the injury. Notice is proven from the hotel's own records, which are unusually good: housekeeping logs showing when a room or hallway was last attended, maintenance tickets for the stair, the railing, the bathtub, inspection checklists for the pool and the fitness equipment, incident reports of prior injuries at the same spot, and surveillance video covering most common areas for days. Those records are requested by preservation letter in the first days and obtained in litigation.

Hotels also owe a duty of reasonable care in the services they provide: food and beverage safety, pool lifeguarding where offered, shuttle and valet driving, and the activities a resort organizes. Each is a negligence claim with its own standard and its own records.

Most hotels carrying a national brand are owned and operated by a franchisee, often a company that owns several properties, or by an owner that has contracted a management company to run it. The brand licenses its name and sets standards but typically does not operate the property, and courts in most states hold the brand liable only where it controlled the specific operation that caused the injury, which is argued from the franchise agreement and the brand's standards and inspections. The operating entity is identified from the state's business records, the hotel's own documents and the franchise disclosures, and its insurer handles the claim.

Resorts, timeshares and condominium hotels add layers: a homeowners' association may control the common areas, a rental management company the units, and a separate operator the amenities, and the injury's location decides which. Cruise ships, tour operators and vacation packages add contractual terms, including notice periods, required courts and waivers, that govern the claim and must be read immediately.

A hotel's contractors, the elevator company, the pool service, the security firm, the restaurant tenant, are defendants when their work caused the injury, with their own policies, and the hotel remains liable for its own failures in selecting and supervising them.

Suppose you were staying at a branded hotel and slipped in the bathtub, which had no mat and no grab bar, fracturing your hip. You were hospitalized in that city for a week, had surgery, and recovered at home over four months, with $71,000 in medical bills and three months off work.

An attorney identified the operator as a franchisee company and sent a preservation letter for the room's housekeeping and maintenance records, prior incident reports and the brand's standards for bathroom safety. The brand's standards, obtained in discovery, required non-slip tub surfaces and grab bars in all rooms; the hotel's maintenance records showed grab bars had been removed from several rooms during a renovation and not reinstalled, and two prior guests had reported falls in tubs without them. That was notice and a departure from the operator's own standard.

The claim ran against the franchisee under its commercial policy, with the brand named on the ground that its inspections had noted the missing grab bars and it had not enforced its standard; the brand's liability was contested and it contributed modestly. The claim settled for the medical bills, the lost wages and the hip injury's effects. All figures are hypothetical; the hotel's own records and standards are the usual evidence.

Hotels document everything, and the guest's job is to make sure the injury is in the record and the record is preserved.

• Report the injury to the front desk or security before you leave the property, and ask for the incident report number and a copy if the hotel will provide one.
• Photograph the hazard, the room, the stair, the pool area or the floor, and the absence of warnings, mats, grab bars or lighting, before it is fixed.
• Get the names of the staff who responded and of any other guests who saw it.
• Get medical care the same day, at the hotel's direction or on your own, and keep the records from the local provider and your providers at home.
• Keep your reservation, folio and any correspondence with the hotel; they identify the operator and the dates.
• Have a preservation letter sent within days for video, housekeeping and maintenance logs, inspection checklists and incident reports; video is overwritten within days.
• Do not sign anything the hotel presents, and do not accept a comped stay or refund in exchange for a release.

The injury is governed by the law of the state where the hotel is, which for a traveler means a state other than home: its premises standard, its comparative negligence rule, its deadline, and any statutes specific to innkeepers, pools or security. A few states apply a single reasonable-care standard rather than invitee categories. Comparative negligence rules, pure in California and New York, a 51 percent bar in Texas, Illinois, Florida and most states, a 50 percent bar in Georgia and Tennessee, and contributory negligence in Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina and Virginia, decide what a guest's own share does.

Negligent security claims, for assaults in rooms, hallways, parking areas and lobbies, depend on the state's foreseeability standard, from prior similar crimes on the premises to a totality-of-circumstances test, and on the security measures the hotel had in place: locks, key card controls, lighting, cameras and staff. Pool injuries are governed by state and local pool codes on fencing, depth markings, drain covers and lifeguards. Food illness claims follow the state's rules on food safety and often strict liability for contaminated food.

Deadlines are the hotel state's injury statute, one year in Tennessee and Kentucky, two in Texas, California, Florida and Georgia, three in New York and North Carolina. A lawsuit is filed where the hotel is, and an attorney licensed there is needed; international resort injuries are governed by the foreign country's law and may be practically unrecoverable, with the tour operator's or travel insurer's terms as the remaining avenue.

Hotel pool injuries, drownings and near-drownings of children, diving injuries in shallow water, slips on pool decks and entrapment in drains, are among the most serious hotel claims, and they turn on compliance with pool codes, the adequacy of depth markings and signage, fencing and gates, the presence or absence of lifeguards where the hotel chose to provide them, and the operator's supervision of the area. Hot tubs bring their own temperature and drain issues.

Negligent security claims arise from assaults and robberies of guests in rooms, hallways, elevators and parking areas, where the hotel's key card system, lighting, cameras, staffing and response to prior incidents are examined against the crime history of the property and its surroundings, which police records establish. Room entry by someone the front desk gave a key to, or a door lock that failed, is a direct claim.

Bed bug claims, for bites and the infestation carried home, depend on the hotel's pest control records and prior complaints, and are modest unless the reaction was severe or the home infestation costly. Food and beverage claims for illness follow the restaurant rules, with the hotel's food safety records and the health department's inspection history as evidence.

A hotel injury claim is a premises claim against an operator that keeps thorough records of its own notice, governed by the law of the state where the property is, with the operator identified from behind the brand and the records preserved before video is overwritten. The questions to answer early are who operates the property, what the records and video show, and what the hotel state's rules and deadline are. Most personal injury attorneys work on contingency and arrange licensed counsel in the hotel's state.

Ask Legal Matters is a free claim-review request service, not a law firm. Requests may be shared with independent attorneys and legal services partners who handle inquiries in the state where you were hurt, and an attorney must evaluate the facts before anyone can say what the claim is worth. If you were injured at a hotel or resort, you can request a free claim review before the records are gone.

• Slip, Trip and Fall Claims: Premises Liability Explained
• Medical Malpractice Claims: Standard of Care, Deadlines and Damages
• Wrongful Death Claims: Who Can File, Deadlines and Damages
• Accident in a Borrowed Car: Whose Insurance Pays
• Accident on Icy Roads or in Bad Weather: Who Is at Fault
• Airbag Did Not Deploy in a Crash: Can You Sue, and Whom?
• Amputation Injury Claim: Prosthetics and Lifetime Costs
• At Fault in a Car Accident? Comparative Negligence Explained
• What Is the Average Car Accident Settlement? What Sets the Value

Need local rules? Choose your state from the injury law guides hub or read the statute of limitations by state.