Fatal car crashes in Flagstaff, AZ: deadliest roads, 2020-2024

From 2020 through 2024, federal crash records list 65 fatal crashes inside Flagstaff, in which 70 people died. The roads with the most were I-40 with 18 fatal crashes, US-89 with 12 and I-17 with 6.

Filing deadline, fault rule, insurance and the court for a crash in Flagstaff: Flagstaff, AZ injury guide.

FARS opens a record whenever a crash on a public road kills someone within 30 days, pulling details from police reports and other state files. Flagstaff's 2023 entry holds 17 crashes and 20 deaths, all in Coconino County. Deaths outnumber crashes by 3, which means one or more crashes took two or more lives, although the summary does not show how those deaths were spread. Eleven crash sites are coded urban and 6 rural. Weather was clear for 12 crashes and cloudy for 3, with 1 in rain and 1 coded as other.

Collisions between moving vehicles are the main story. Eleven crashes, about 65 percent, began with one moving vehicle striking another: 5 front-to-rear impacts, the FARS label for rear-end crashes, 2 head-on, 2 angle, and 1 sideswipe each between vehicles traveling in opposite directions and in the same direction. The first harmful event, a FARS term for the earliest moment of injury or damage, was a pedestrian in 2 crashes and a rollover in 2, while a ditch and a bridge pier or support were each struck first once.

FARS counts 3 crashes as involving a non-motorist, a category that takes in pedestrians, cyclists and a few other groups. A pedestrian was the first harmful event in 2 of them; the third began with a different first harmful event. Light conditions split into 10 daylight crashes, 3 in the dark on lighted roads, 3 in the dark without lighting and 1 at dusk. Only 2 crashes fall in the overnight hours of 9 p.m. to 4:59 a.m., so at least 4 of the 6 dark crashes came during evening or early-morning hours.

Twelve crashes happened away from any junction, 2 within intersections, and 1 apiece in an intersection-related area, elsewhere in an interchange area and on a through roadway. Monday had 5 crashes and Thursday 4; Tuesday, Friday and Sunday had 2 each, and Wednesday and Saturday 1 each. May and August had 3 apiece, July, October, November and December 2 each, and April, June and September 1 each. January, February and March had none, but 17 crashes are too few to establish a seasonal pattern.

By road class, other principal arterials carried 6 crashes, interstates 5 and minor arterials 4, while the major-collector and minor-collector categories had 1 apiece. Arterials of both kinds account for 10 of the 17 crashes, and interstates for about 29 percent. Flagstaff's road list is complete: its 9 entries add up to all 17 crashes, so every fatal crash in the city's 2023 file can be tied to a named road.

US-89 alone accounts for 6 crashes, a little more than a third of the total, and I-40 for 4. Townsend-Winona Road appears under two spellings, one hyphenated and one not, with 1 crash under each; they are listed as coded. Heavily traveled routes collect more crashes partly because so many vehicles use them, so the list below says where deaths occurred, not how risky each road is per trip:

• US-89: 6 fatal crashes.
• I-40: 4.
• I-17 and SR-66: 1 each.
• CR-Lake Mary Rd, E Industrial Dr and Forest Service Rd 545: 1 each.
• Townsend-Winona Rd and Townsend Winona Rd, two spellings as coded: 1 each.

The summary records how crashes began, not why, and it holds no data on speed, traffic volume or impairment, so explanations for Flagstaff's pattern are possibilities to be tested. Rear-end crashes commonly involve a following driver who is distracted, following too closely or moving too fast to stop when traffic slows. NHTSA's speeding page warns that higher speed means a longer stop and a harder impact, two effects that matter most when one vehicle runs into the back of another.

Daylight is the other notable feature: 10 crashes happened in daylight, and 15 of the 17 fall outside the overnight hours. Daytime crashes on busy arterials and interstates can reflect heavier traffic, frequent slowing and lane changes, but the summary cannot confirm any of that. Six locations are classed as rural, and rural roads can involve higher speeds and longer waits for emergency help, though the data does not show whether either applied in these crashes.

Crash type shapes the evidence a claim needs. After a rear-end collision, insurers usually look first at the following driver, since a trailing driver is expected to keep a gap large enough to stop in, but they may still argue that the lead driver braked suddenly or had a broken brake light. Under Arizona's pure comparative negligence rule, any share pinned on you lowers your recovery without ending it. In the 2 head-on and 2 angle crashes, lane position and right of way move to the center, and a passenger hurt in a rollover usually claims against the driver's liability coverage.

Suppose you were stopped in traffic on a Flagstaff arterial one afternoon when a pickup failed to slow down and struck the back of your car. You suffered a herniated disk in your neck and a broken wrist. Medical care cost $45,000, and eight weeks away from your job cost $10,000 in wages. These numbers are made up to illustrate the rules and do not come from any actual case.

Arizona assigns payment by fault, so your claim would go to the pickup driver's liability insurer. The insurer accepts that its driver hit you but says one of your brake lights was out, and it wants to put 20 percent of the blame on you. Valuing your full damages, pain and suffering included, at $120,000, a 20 percent share would cut your recovery to $96,000. Under Arizona's pure comparative rule, even a far larger share would shrink the award rather than erase it.

The next hurdle is coverage. A pickup driver insured at Arizona's floor of 25/50/15 can pay you no more than $25,000 under that policy, well below $96,000. Underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy may make up part of the difference, and an attorney might examine whether an employer is also responsible if the pickup was being driven for work. Only an attorney who reviews the facts of a real crash can say whether it supports a claim and what that claim might be worth.

Most of Flagstaff's 2023 fatal crashes began with one vehicle striking another, most happened in daylight, and nearly all were on arterials or interstates, so the steps below focus on following distance, braking, lane position and witnesses. Drivers, passengers and people on foot can all use them, and a family member can handle several. Begin promptly, because skid marks fade, vehicles are repaired and video is deleted.

• Call 911, ask which law enforcement agency is taking the report and keep the report number.
• If it is safe, photograph the damage to both vehicles, where they came to rest, the brake lights and any tire marks, ideally before anything is moved.
• Write down what traffic was doing just before the impact, such as slowing for a signal, merging or stopping in a queue.
• Get the other driver's insurance details and ask whether the vehicle was being used for work.
• Keep your vehicle, or at least its event data recorder, from being repaired or scrapped until the data has been preserved.
• See a doctor promptly even if the pain seems minor, since neck and back injuries can worsen over several days.
• Calendar the two-year lawsuit deadline, plus the 180-day notice deadline if a road condition or government vehicle may be involved.

Arizona follows pure comparative negligence. A claimant's damages drop in step with his or her own percentage of blame, but the claim never disappears, so someone found 80 percent at fault can still collect the remaining 20 percent. California, Washington, Missouri and New York take the same pure approach. Nevada, Ohio and Texas end recovery once a person's fault exceeds 50 percent, and Colorado and Nebraska once it reaches 50 percent, while Maryland and North Carolina, which keep contributory negligence, can deny a claim for even slight fault.

Because Arizona is a fault state, payment for an injury generally comes from the liability insurer of whoever caused the crash. Florida, Minnesota and Utah work differently: as no-fault states, they send injured people to personal injury protection on their own auto policies before anything else and generally restrict suits for pain and suffering. Arizona's mandatory minimum is 25/50/15. The first two numbers cap bodily-injury payments at $25,000 a person and $50,000 a crash, and the third caps property damage at $15,000; the coverage actually in effect on the date of the crash is what applies.

Arizona's two-year limit for most injury lawsuits comes from A.R.S. § 12-542. A wrongful death claim has two years as well, but the period runs from the death rather than the injury (A.R.S. § 12-542(2)). Suing a city, a county or the state also means serving a notice of claim first, and A.R.S. § 12-821.01(A) allows only 180 days for that step, far less than the lawsuit deadline. The general period is four years in Utah and Nebraska, three in Washington and Maryland and five in Missouri. In Arizona, injury lawsuits are generally brought in Superior Court.

Flagstaff's 2023 data points to collisions between moving vehicles, rear-end impacts most of all, with US-89 and I-40 accounting for 10 of the 17 fatal crashes. Under Arizona law, the at-fault driver's liability coverage is the first place to look, any shared blame reduces rather than ends the recovery, most lawsuits face a two-year clock and a public body must get notice within 180 days. On fees, most personal injury attorneys work on contingency; before hiring one, ask about the percentage and about who pays case costs.

Ask Legal Matters is a lead-generation service, not a law firm. Anyone hurt in a Flagstaff crash, or a family that lost someone in one, can use the free claim-review request service it offers, which stops short of advising anyone on the law. Requests may be shared with independent attorneys and legal services partners who handle inquiries in Arizona. An attorney would have to weigh the facts before anyone could say a Flagstaff claim exists. If US-89, I-40 or any other Flagstaff road was where you were hurt, you can request a free claim review.

• Flagstaff, Arizona: local injury guide, court and deadlines
• Car Accident Claims in the United States: The Complete Guide
• Wrongful Death Claims: Who Can File, Deadlines and Damages
• Fatal car crashes in Goodyear, AZ: deadliest roads, 2020-2024
• Fatal car crashes in Chandler, AZ: deadliest roads, 2020-2024
• Fatal car crashes in Tucson, AZ: deadliest roads, 2020-2024
• Traumatic Brain Injury Car Accident Claim: How It Is Built
• Spinal Cord Injury From a Car Accident: How the Claim Works
• Loss of Consortium Claim for a Spouse After an Injury

Need local rules? Choose your state from the injury law guides hub or read the statute of limitations by state.