Ask Legal MattersInjury resource blog

Car & road accidents

What to Do With a Child Car Seat After a Crash

Get a free case review

Do you replace a car seat after a crash? What pages on government sites say about the minor-crash checklist, insurance, disposal and recalls.

By Ask Legal Matters Editorial Team · Published · How we prepare these guides

Injured in an accident?
Share what happened using our free request form.

Free case review

Replace a child car seat after a moderate or severe crash; after a minor crash, the seat may not need to be replaced. That is how a Wisconsin Child Passenger Safety card (a 2021 Children's Wisconsin card posted on the Washington Ozaukee Public Health Department's site) reports the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) recommendation, and the card follows it with a checklist in which every item must be true before a crash counts as minor. On what to do with a car seat after an accident, the same card says to call "the car seat manufacturer for guidance on whether your car/booster seat can still be used."

NHTSA's own page did not load for our check, so we did not read NHTSA's current wording. The quotes below come from pages on government sites; only the Wisconsin card names NHTSA.

Do I need to replace a car seat after a crash?

The Wisconsin card (marked "2021 Children's Wisconsin") puts it this way: "The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) recommends that car seats be replaced following a moderate or severe crash. Car seats may not need to be replaced after a minor crash."

Utah's Click It Utah site says: "Always replace a car seat after a moderate or severe crash. If the crash was minor, consult the seat manufacturer's instructions to see if it is still safe to use."

What counts as a minor crash?

After naming NHTSA's recommendation, the Wisconsin card says: "A minor crash is one in which ALL of the following apply:" and then lists the items in the table below. The right-hand cells are the card's own words; we did not read them on NHTSA's page.

Crash detailWhat the Wisconsin card says
Whether the vehicle could be driven"The vehicle was able to be driven away from the crash site."
The door next to the seat"The vehicle door nearest the car seat was not damaged."
Injuries"None of the passengers in the vehicle sustained any injuries in the crash."
Air bags"If the vehicle has air bags, the air bags did not deploy during the crash."
The seat itself"There is no visible damage to the car seat."

A Texas Department of State Health Services presentation (Safe Riders program) lists the same five items in its own words, without naming NHTSA. It says "Car seats do not always need to be replaced following a minor crash" and "A minor crash is defined when ALL the following applies:" before its list.

Does the car seat maker's rule matter?

Yes. Several of the pages we read send parents to the manufacturer after a crash, and some pages are stricter than the minor-crash checklist.

  • The Colorado Department of Transportation's car seat FAQ says: "Some manufacturers will require replacement after any crash, while others may state to replace the seat after a moderate to severe crash. You can also find crash replacement guidelines in the car seat owner's manual."
  • The Wisconsin card says: "Always follow car seat manufacturer's instructions."
  • A Kentucky Office of Highway Safety fact sheet has no minor-crash exception. It says: "If the seat has been involved in a crash, it should be replaced."
  • The New York Governor's Traffic Safety Committee, in its checklist for used seats, says: "Never use a seat that has been involved in a crash."

Does insurance pay to replace a car seat after an accident?

The pages we read do not give one answer. The Wisconsin card says to contact your auto insurance company "to find out if they will reimburse you for a replacement car/booster seat after a crash."

We read one state's legislation for this article: the signed act of Colorado House Bill 25-1179, which reads "In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 10-4-644 as follows:". The new section says: "AN INSURER THAT ISSUES OR RENEWS A POLICY PURSUANT TO THIS PART 6 SHALL INCLUDE IN THE APPLICABLE COVERAGE THE REPLACEMENT COST OF A CHILD RESTRAINT SYSTEM THAT IS IN A MOTOR VEHICLE AT THE TIME OF A MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENT, AND TO WHICH THE COVERAGE IN THE POLICY IS APPLICABLE." It also says "THE INSURER SHALL ASK THE CLAIMANT IF A CHILD RESTRAINT SYSTEM WAS IN THE MOTOR VEHICLE AT THE TIME THAT THE ACCIDENT OCCURRED".

The act was signed with an effective date that depends on no referendum petition being filed: "This act takes effect January 1, 2026; except that, if a referendum petition is filed", followed by the steps for that case. It "applies to automobile insurance policies issued or renewed and insurance claims filed on or after the applicable effective date of this act." We did not check whether a petition was filed, and we did not read the current Colorado statute.

Pages from other states mention insurance without citing a law:

  • The Texas presentation says: "Some vehicle insurance providers will replace the child safety seat if it is unusable after a crash."
  • Connecticut's Department of Motor Vehicles page says: "Most car insurances will cover for a car seat replacement."
  • The Kentucky fact sheet says: "Check with your insurance company before purchasing a new seat."

None of those three lines is a legal rule. The Texas presentation adds: "The caregiver will need to contact their vehicle insurance provider for further instructions." Our guide on how to file a car insurance claim after an accident covers the claim steps, and our car accident records checklist lists papers to keep after a crash.

How do I get rid of a car seat that was in a crash?

One page we read answers this for crashed seats (Colorado); the South Carolina line below is about expired seats.

  • Expired or crashed seats, Colorado: under the question "What should I do with an expired or crashed car seat?", the Colorado Department of Transportation FAQ says "Car seats that are damaged, expired, or outgrown can be recycled at one of our locations around the state." Its recycling page says "Never reuse a car seat involved in a crash." and "There is no cost to recycle your car seat."
  • Expired seats, South Carolina: a South Carolina Department of Public Health booklet says that when a seat expires, "the harness straps should be cut so it can no longer be used and should be disposed of." For crashed seats the same booklet says only: "Contact the car seat manufacturer to determine if a car seat can still be used after it has been involved in a crash."

Outside Colorado, the pages we read did not give disposal steps for crashed seats; the South Carolina disposal line is about expired seats.

How do I check for recalls and register the new seat?

Click It Utah says: "Fill out the registration card that comes with your seat or go to the car seat manufacturer website to register. This is the only way the manufacturer can contact you directly if there is a safety recall."

To check a seat for recalls, the New York checklist says: "You will need the name of the car seat manufacturer, model number or serial number and date that it was manufactured." It links to NHTSA's recall list.

Where can I get a car seat checked?

Connecticut's page says: "Fitting Stations are locations that offer free child safety seat checks and education."

The Kentucky fact sheet says: "Contact your local fire station, police department, health department or other safety-related agency and ask if they have a certified child passenger safety technician on staff."

Common questions

Does a booster seat follow the same guidance?

The Colorado FAQ says: "Contact the car seat or booster seat manufacturer with any questions about whether the seat needs to be replaced after a crash."

Do I need a new seat if no child was riding in it?

The minor-crash list on the Wisconsin card has no line about whether a child was in the seat. The card's line is to call the manufacturer "After any crash".

Can I sell or give away a seat that was in a crash?

The checklists we read for secondhand seats ask about crash history. New York's checklist for used seats says: "Verify from the previous owner that the car seat has never been involved in a vehicle crash." Colorado's checklist includes "The car seat or booster seat has never been involved in a crash."

If you were injured in a crash, you can request a free case review. Your request may be shared with independent attorneys.

---

This is general information, not legal advice. Ask Legal Matters is a free case-review request service, not a law firm.

Sources

Sources checked November 15, 2026.

Find the right local record source

Use the state hub for statewide agencies and the community directory to locate the place where the incident happened. The agency that responded may differ from the nearest city.

Choose your state · Find your community

Related: What Happens If the Other Driver Has No Insurance?

Related: Do You Have to Call the Police If You Hit a Deer?

Related: What Is BuyCrash and How Do You Get a Crash Report?

Related: How to Get a California Highway Patrol Crash Report

Related: How to Get a Texas Crash Report Through CRIS

Ready to explain what happened?

Request a free personal injury case review using our existing form. We may share your request with independent attorneys and legal services partners. Availability depends on your state and case type.

Request a free case review

Ask Legal Matters is a lead-generation service, not a law firm. A request does not create an attorney-client relationship or guarantee contact, representation or a recovery. Read the contact consent on the form before submitting.

See Ask Legal Matters first in Google Search.

Free case review →Chat
with us